Christmas movies are part of most people' favorite parts of the holiday season, and everyone has their own Top XX List. Some are distinctly Christmasy, but nothing says a Christmas movie has to include Santa, reindeer, or a gaggle of elves! Since my new holiday comedy, Christmas Movie Night, is being released next Monday, I'm sharing what I think are the best holiday movies - including some nontraditional Christmas movies - to sit around with family and friends (and hopefully not any deceptive interlopers to the party). In no particular order, here are my 15 favorite Christmas (ish) movies. So grab some popcorn, put on your comfiest Christmas socks, and drop me a line to let me know what you think of my choices!
1. Die Hard - Okay, so I just said no particular order, but come on. I had to start with the greatest Christmas movie of all time. Can you believe the role of John McClane was first offered to Frank Sinatra? That would have been a VERY different movie. Everything in this classic is perfect, from Hans Gruber's sinister accent to McClane's cocky yet frazzled cop to "Special Agent Johnson. Special Agent Johnson, no relation."
2. National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation - This is the one that we watch at Movie Night every single year, no matter what. There are just so many memorable scenes, so many laugh out loud quotes, so many instances of complete Griswold craziness. When Snots the dog yaks on a bone under the dinner table, I still laugh out loud every time.
3. Scrooged - I like Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol just fine, but of all the versions ever made, this is the one that I enjoy watching the most. Frank Cross, a modern day TV executive from hell, channeling his best Ebenezer Scrooge, is hellbent on putting on the most commercially successful Christmas Eve world-wide programming event in history. A few ghosts would like to talk to him, including the hilariously S&M-minded Ghost of Christmas Present.
4. Elf - Talk about a quotable movie. "You sit on a throne of lies." "He's an angry elf!" "Watch out, the yellow ones don't stop!" All wrapped up in a genuinely sweet, funny story. Unless you have a gripe against Will Ferrell because you don't like how he portrayed George W Bush on SNL, how can you possibly not love this movie?
5. Christmas with the Kranks - Based on the John Grisham novel, Skipping Christmas, this is a fun watch every year. Jamie Lee Curtis and Tim Allen make a fun ornery couple who decide to duck out on all family/friend/HOA Christmas roles and responsibilities so they can take a Caribbean cruise instead. Some of the sight gags are hilarious, and the ending is redemptively sweet.
6. Jingle All the Way - This is a totally cheesy movie that has awful acting and a ridiculous plot if you give it too much thought. Don't give it too much thought. Just go with ARR-NOLT pulling his Austrian hair out trying to get the hot and sold-out toy of the year for his ungrateful brat of a son. And every year, it's a bittersweet treat to see the late great Phil Hartman onscreen again as the sniveling neighbor trying to horn in on Arnold's wife.
7. Home Alone - Kevin McCallister is a psychopath in the making. Yeah, I said it. He's a shrimpy little motor-mouth with an abrasive personality who should probably be brought up on attempted murder charges. Still, this is such a mainstay of the holiday season, we just have to watch it every year. I'm not sitting through the 57 sequels, though.
8. It's a Wonderful Life - The ultimate Capra-corn. A true Christmas classic. We always have this movie playing during dinner on Christmas Movie Night because it's so long and it's so ingrained in everyone's subconscious that almost all of us could quote it from memory. Zuzu's petals can bring a tear to any grown man's eye.
9. The Muppet Christmas Carol - It's A Christmas Carol, but with Muppets. And a few humans, like that guy who played Batman's butler and one of the Dirty Rotten Scoundrels.
10. Trading Places - This one may not be thought of as a traditional Christmas movie, but there is of course the scene where Dan Aykroyd's character puts on a Santa suit, gets drunk at a party, and smuggles an entire salmon out under his suit, eating it through his fake beard. Aykroyd, Murphy, and Curtis are all wonderful in this film, and seeing them stick it to the crotchety old Duke brothers fills my heart with holiday cheer every year.
11. 8-Bit Christmas - This is a newer one, from the HBO streaming service. Imagine The Princess Bride, except instead of Peter Falk telling his grandson the story, it's Dougie Howser telling his daughter, and instead of the story being a swashbuckling tale of danger, love, and piracy, it's a story of a kid doing everything he can think of to get his first Nintendo game system. My wife and son and I loved it the first time we saw it, but we haven't been successful in working it into the Movie Night rotation.
12. Love the Coopers - At first glance, it's another cheesy, soapy, multi-story film about dysfunctional relationships at the holiday time. But upon rewatching it and actually paying attention, I truly enjoyed the character development, crisscrossing storylines, and narration by the dog with Steve Martin's voice.
13. You've Got Mail - Who doesn't love Tom Hanks and/or Meg Ryan?
14. The Santa Clause - The sequels are very hit or miss, but this first entry is a lot of fun. If you can overlook the casual, comedic nature of Santa Claus' tragic death in the first ten minutes, this is a well-done movie with plenty of laughs, memorable moments, and North Pole magic.
15. The Nightmare before Christmas - What an awesome movie this one is. The story, the animation, the songs, the humor - it's all top-notch! All Jack Skellington knows is Halloween and spooky tricks and treats, but he longs for something more. When he gets a chance to step into Santa's shoes, his idea of gift giving throws the world into chaos.
Who knows? Maybe someday I can add the movie adaptation of Christmas Movie Night to this list of favorites and Christmas movie recommendations. In the meantime, if you're looking for a funny Christmas book that celebrates fun, family night that go off the rails in spectacular fashion (especially when random, possibly-criminal elements are introduced), why not pick up a copy and enjoy the movie references?